artifacts/standard-named

Rendered from markdown source. Open raw source on GitHub.

J.1 Validation Report

Status: completed Validation date: 2026-07-15

Source and schema validation

Python source modules compiled: PASS (19)
JSON files parsed: PASS
JSON Schemas checked: 12
schema errors: 0

The twelve schemas are:

Six consolidated constitutional families

• center-standing.schema.json
• source-projection-context.schema.json
• purpose-authority-role.schema.json
• route-gate-action-consequence.schema.json
• event-witness-contest-repair.schema.json
• lifecycle-transfer-residual.schema.json

Six J.1 hardening profiles

• authorization-policy.schema.json
• verification-signature.schema.json
• context-revision.schema.json
• disclosure-profile.schema.json
• correction-reachability.schema.json
• tool-transaction.schema.json

Automated tests

unit and integration tests: 13
test failures: 0
test errors: 0

Tested behavior includes:

• concurrent SQLite event appends;
• event-chain verification;
• stale object-write rejection;
• policy version enforcement;
• stale-context rejection;
• gate-key revocation;
• full hardened scenario;
• restart restoration of policy, key, and retirement state;
• tampered-manifest rejection;
• independent standalone verification;
• partial tool failure and compensation;
• selective-disclosure privacy;
• sixteen-case threat harness;
• accessibility structure;
• twelve-schema validity.

Reference scenario result

final step: retired
active authorization policy: version 2
context revision: 2
gate-k1: revoked
gate-k2: revoked
gate-k3: active
tool credential active: false

Required proofs

failed gate: true
valid action: true
consequence return: true
correction propagation: true
retirement revocation: true
stale-context rejection: true
policy-version enforcement: true
key rotation and revoked-token rejection: true
partial-failure compensation: true
selective disclosure: true

Correction reachability

known descendants: 4
updated descendants: 4
blocked descendants outside accounting: 0
unreachable descendants: 0
complete for scope: true

Event and object store

reference events: 20
reference objects: 46
event-chain integrity: PASS
concurrent append test: PASS
stale revision overwrite test: PASS

Adversarial harness

threat cases: 16
threat cases detected: 16
undetected cases: 0

The additional J.1 cases beyond HI-S are:

• policy downgrade;
• stale-context execution;
• revoked-key reuse;
• selective-disclosure leakage;
• hidden partial tool failure;
• concurrent stale object write.

Witness export

Implementation verifier:

valid: true
checksums verified: 34
records validated: 46
events verified: 20
selective views verified: 4
manifest signature valid: true

Standalone verifier:

valid: true
implementation package imported: false
Ed25519 signature verified: true
provider connection required: false

Accessibility structural review

Automated structure checks passed for:

• language declaration;
• skip link;
• main landmark;
• keyboard-native controls;
• live status region;
• reduced-motion preference;
• forced-colors support;
• accessibility statement.

This is not a WCAG certification or user study.

Scope of validation

This report establishes internal structural and behavioral validation of the synthetic reference pilot.

It does not establish:

• legal compliance;
• production security;
• real-world privacy protection;
• external accessibility conformance;
• safety in high-stakes domains;
• resilience under distributed infrastructure failure;
• independent governance legitimacy;
• scientific proof of Telic Field theory.

Result

PASS WITH CONDITIONS

Conditions before an external pilot:

• externally controlled signing-key custody;
• authenticated participants and operators;
• domain-specific privacy review;
• external accessibility testing;
• network and distributed-failure testing;
• independent security review;
• real multi-party correction exercise;
• repository ingestion and independent build validation.