artifacts/standard-named

Rendered from markdown source. Open raw source on GitHub.

HI-2 Validation Report

Status: completed Validation date: 2026-07-15

Schema validation

The following ten candidate Draft 2020-12 schemas were checked:

• field-classification.schema.json
• route.schema.json
• route-portfolio.schema.json
• cost-bearer-record.schema.json
• protected-condition-review.schema.json
• decision-rule-declaration.schema.json
• governance-gate.schema.json
• model-recommendation.schema.json
• decision-witness.schema.json
• consequence-review.schema.json

Result:

schemas checked: 10
schema errors: 0

Positive demonstrations

All seven required demonstrations passed:

1. two Pareto-efficient routes remained unresolved;
2. a protected condition blocked an otherwise efficient route;
3. missing standing caused pause;
4. a route portfolio preserved legitimate plurality;
5. a DecisionWitness was generated from an event stream;
6. observed consequence caused route revision;
7. model recommendation remained recommendation only.

Result:

positive demonstrations passed: 7
positive failures: 0

Negative conformance cases

All twelve prohibited patterns were detected:

1. hidden scalar sovereignty;
2. protected-condition compensation;
3. missing standing represented as zero;
4. Pareto efficiency represented as legitimacy;
5. model recommendation treated as authorization;
6. route consideration treated as consent;
7. eventless witness;
8. consequence overwrite;
9. no-decision erasure;
10. route-portfolio collapse;
11. undeclared decision rule;
12. omitted cost bearer.

Result:

negative cases detected: 12
undetected negative cases: 0

Event-generated witness

The witness generator read:

• the decision event stream;
• structured witness context;
• referenced route, gate, recommendation, and classification records.

The generated witness validated against decision-witness.schema.json.

Result:

generated_from_events: true
event order preserved: true
selected route derived from route_selected event: true
model recommendation retained separately: true

Independent witness export

The decision-witness demonstration export contains:

• event stream;
• generated witness;
• route comparison;
• protected-condition gate;
• missing-standing gate;
• route portfolio;
• model recommendation;
• schemas;
• manifest;
• checksums.

Result:

checksum files verified: 17
checksum failures: 0
independent_of_recommendation_model: true

Public-page consistency review

H.2 was checked against I.2 for the following distinctions:

• field, projection, and receiver mirror remain distinct;
• private access does not create disclosure authority;
• consent is scoped to artifact, recipient, purpose, duration, and downstream use;
• source correction can stop inference laundering before disclosure;
• witness does not require merger or total surveillance;
• model mediation does not create adjudication authority;
• inadequate context may require ask, narrow, pause, escalate, fork, or stop.

Result:

technical/public contradictions found: 0

Scope of validation

This report establishes structural and internal semantic validation only.

It does not establish:

• fairness of the example decision;
• completeness of cost-bearer discovery;
• legitimacy of protected-condition authority in every domain;
• production security;
• legal compliance;
• model neutrality;
• public-reader comprehension;
• scientific validity of the broader Telic Field framework.

Conditions before production use

• authenticate standing and protected-condition authority;
• test cost-bearer discovery against real institutional workflows;
• implement decision-rule sensitivity analysis;
• test event-generated witness creation against a production event store;
• implement independent route and gate review;
• conduct privacy and strategic-manipulation threat modeling;
• conduct independent reader testing of H.1 and H.2.