artifacts/standard-named

Rendered from markdown source. Open raw source on GitHub.

Semantic Trails — Comparison and Boundary Matrix

Status: draft Content canon status: unset

| Neighboring concept | Existing contribution | Candidate Telic Field addition | |---|---|---| | Semiotics | Sign, object, interpretant, mediation | Standing, consent, authority, correction, and action governance | | Pragmatism | Meaning through use, consequence, and habit | Durable witness and lifecycle of practical distinctions | | Teleosemantics | Function, proper use, and representational normativity | Social, institutional, consent, and machine-mediated trails | | Biosemiotics | Sign processes in living systems | Cross-domain governance of persistent traces | | Semantic information | Meaningful or truth-related information | False but causally powerful traces and action authority | | Affordances | Organism-relative possibilities for action | Historically produced trails that reveal or reshape affordances | | Stigmergy | Indirect coordination through environmental traces | Provenance, standing, correction, privacy, and ownership | | Niche construction | Inherited environmental modification | Interpretable traces and consent-governed semantic inheritance | | Distributed cognition | Cognition across people and artifacts | Authority, correction, and participant standing | | Transactive memory | Group knowledge of who knows what | Consent, privacy, machine custodians, and succession | | Collective memory | Socially organized public remembering | Trace-level source, transformation, and action records | | Archives and documents | Durable, selective, institutionally governed evidence | Telic function, semantic lifecycle, and release | | RDF and knowledge graphs | Machine-readable entities and relations | Status-bearing edges with scope, authority, and contest | | W3C PROV | Entities, activities, agents, and derivations | Standing, consent, semantic integrity, uptake, and release | | Cultural evolution | Transmission, selection, innovation, and drift | Contributor standing and legitimate use | | LLM semantic participation | Transformation and generation of linguistic traces | Non-sovereign role, provider disclosure, provenance, and correction |

Governing distinctions

terrain ≠ trail
trace ≠ meaning
persistence ≠ integrity
information ≠ truth
truth ≠ legitimacy
graph edge ≠ source field
machine readability ≠ authority
shared access ≠ commons governance
provenance ≠ consent
correction ≠ erasure
reactivation ≠ continuing validity

Terminology warning

Semantic field already has established meanings.

Every Telic Field use must include the scoped definition:

The distributed, revisable ecology of traces, conventions, artifacts, relations, and interpretive practices through which prior distinctions become available to current and future navigation.

A narrower technical alternative is:

semantic-trail ecology