artifacts/standard-named

Rendered from markdown source. Open raw source on GitHub.

Annotation, Preference, Constitution, and Synthetic Ancestry Matrix

Status: candidate pre-production Content canon status: unset

| Layer | Must preserve | Must not become | |---|---|---| | Annotation | Contributor, role, instructions, conditions, compensation, authority | Invisible free semantic labor | | Demonstration | Task, source, intended behavior, downstream scope | Universal example of human desire | | Ranking | Candidate set, preference context, disagreement | Humanity's preference | | Critique | Reviewer basis, evidence, scope | Absolute truth | | Reward model | Preference source, aggregation, objective, biases | Public legitimacy engine | | DPO or RLHF record | Dataset, method, disagreement treatment, provider role | Consent generator | | AI feedback | Generating model, constitution, source dependence | Human judgment | | Constitution | Authors, authority, adoption, conflicts, revisions | Legitimate merely because explicit | | Synthetic data | Generating model, prompts, ancestors, restrictions, depth | Source-free material | | Distillation | Teacher lineage, target purpose, restrictions | New model without ancestry | | Evaluation | Evaluator, benchmark purpose, limitations | General legitimacy proof |

Preference record minimum

task
contributors
instructions
working conditions
compensation
source inputs
output type
preference context
disagreement
quality control
authority
consent
downstream use
withdrawal

Constitution record minimum

principles
principle sources
authors or authorities
affected centers
adoption process
training or inference use
conflicts
exceptions
revision history
contest route

Synthetic ancestry minimum

generating models
generation process
ancestor sources
ancestor authority
ancestor restrictions
transformations
filtering
contamination risks
recursive depth
withdrawal links

Governing principles

Preference data is a projection of judgment under a task, not a sample from a single human telos.

Synthetic does not mean unowned, unbiased, source-free, or consent-free.