artifacts/standard-named

Rendered from markdown source. Open raw source on GitHub.

Standing, Option Construction, and Protected Conditions Matrix

Status: candidate pre-production Content canon status: unset

| Governance question | Required record | Primary failure | Required response | |---|---|---|---| | Who is affected? | Public-field assembly | Material consequence bearer absent | Add standing, represent, or pause | | Why may a center participate? | Standing-admission record | Expertise or authority substituted for affected standing | Separate roles and scopes | | Who speaks for an absent center? | Representation source and limits | Representation asserted without source | Admit conditionally or contest | | Which routes exist? | Option-set witness | Agenda or option-set capture | Expand, combine, or reopen options | | Who authored the route? | Option source and author class | Model or staff option presented as public demand | Correct authorship | | Why was a route excluded? | Exclusion reason | Omission recorded as rejection | Restore as omitted or reopen | | Which conditions resist tradeoff? | Protected-condition declaration | Boundary converted to weight | Apply noncompensatory gate | | Who may override protection? | Override process | Rhetorical veto or silent override | Competent review | | Which statement is a position? | Deliberative assertion class | Position, evidence, and prediction collapsed | Relabel and correct | | Which summary governs? | Correctable active summary | Model summary treated as field | Participant review and correction |

Standing distinctions

standing ≠ factual correctness
expertise ≠ affected standing
representation ≠ ownership
admission ≠ veto
participation ≠ implementation authority

Option-set minimum

included options
excluded options
combined options
source of each option
author class
exclusion reason
affected centers
challenge route
freeze time

Protected-condition minimum

condition
protected centers
source
scope
evidence
authority
override process
review
status

Governing principle

The public field is shaped before any vote by who is admitted, which routes are imaginable, and which losses are permitted to enter tradeoff.